JCMartinell
2 out of 5 stars: Vain repititions
Reviewed in the United States on April 11, 2026
Format: Kindle
Verified Purchase
My readerverified score is 15%. It is clear to me that this author is not a biblical expert, and I strongly disagree with his assessment of baptism. Honestly, I could write an entire book explaining why his conclusions don’t hold up. I encourage readers to study Scripture for themselves so they aren’t misled.
The book begins with a word study on baptism, and I will say that part is well researched—it's the only reason I gave this book two stars. However, despite his own findings pointing clearly toward immersion, he doesn't conclude that baptism is done by immersion. Instead, he uses his research to support his personal belief that water baptism no longer applies to God’s people today.
In my view, the author’s argument relies heavily on twisting Paul’s writings rather than following what Jesus taught.
One example is how he pulls 1 Corinthians 1:17 out of context—where Paul says he was sent to preach, not to baptize. The author uses this and a few similar verses repeatedly to argue that water baptism has been done away with. He circles back to the same passages so often that it feels like he’s trying to convince not only the reader, but himself.
He also claims that Peter preached a different gospel than Paul, which contradicts one of the very verses he quotes: “one Lord, one faith, one baptism.” If there is only one faith, then there is only one gospel.
Another issue is how he separates water baptism and baptism by the Holy Spirit as if they are unrelated. I believe they are two parts of the same whole. Water baptism is our step of commitment—a public declaration of choosing a new life in Christ. Baptism by the Holy Spirit is Jesus working within us, refining us and preparing us to share the gospel. They work together, not in opposition.
Personally, I would rather err on the side of obedience. If Jesus Himself was baptized, then I should take that step too. Isn’t that what following Christ means?
John 3:5
Jesus answered, Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born of water and of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God.
Sorry, I got your portrait and blurb. Thanks, I'm sending this message to everyone and I forgot you sent a portrait already.
Michael, if you send me a picture of the spine of your book, I will add it to the stack of books on the landing page.
Additionally, you can send a portrait with a blurb about working with ReaderVerified and I will add it to the other testimonials.
Hi Michael,
If you send me a portrait of yourself with a short testimonial about ReaderVerified, I will add it to our landing page.
Thanks,
John
Hello, and thank you for the verified review. I have already changed the book cover. Please note the one I sent to you. Thank you I appreciate this service!
Hi Michael,
If you have updated your book cover, pop it into our platform, and I will switch it with the one on display now.
Hi Michael,
I would strongly recommend that you consider creating a new cover for your book. You can read my article about the importance of a good cover design on the ReaderVerified site. Using a site like Canva or ChatGPT, you can design one yourself, or you can use a site like 99designs and let them do it for you.
Let me know your thoughts,
John
Hi Michael,
I reviewed your eBook a while ago, but it took a while for Amazon to post it. I purchased your eBook, but they stated that I purchased your audiobook. Not sure why Amazon made so many mistakes with my review of your book, but I will try to get it straightened out.
Happy New Year!
John